Shop for Good

proceeds support our museum programs | learn more >

Small Business Partners

Curbside pick-up available.

TY Original Pugsley Beanie Baby TY Original Pugsley Beanie Baby
$50.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Condition: Missing Ear Tag

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 

 
1 Dozen TY Sport the Dog Beanie Baby 1 Dozen TY Sport the Dog Beanie Baby
$52.00
Add to Bag

Condition: Good

Date of Birth: September 2nd, 2002

Tag on Ear: I bark and bark the whole day through

But not because I'm mad at you

It's really just the only way

To let you know I want to play!

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 



Curbside pick up available
OR
click to ask about shipping fees
 
5 TY Beanie Baby Grab Bag 5 TY Beanie Baby Grab Bag
$65.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Find beanie babies you'll cherish! We'll choose a variety for you. Five surprise beanie babies in every box.

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items

 
Ty Beanie Baby Pops the Bear 2001 Ty Beanie Baby Pops the Bear 2001
$200.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Condition: Good

Date of Birth: June 16th, 2001

On the Ear Tag: 

My Dad has such a great big heart

He's kind and fun and really smart

He always finds the time to play

I want to be like him someday!

Errors:

Swing tag has 2001 and tush tag has 2002.

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 

 
Ty Retired Beanie Baby Original Butch Terrier Dog Ty Retired Beanie Baby Original Butch Terrier Dog
$200.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Date of Birth: October 2, 1998

On the ear tag: Going to the pet shop to buy dog food

I ran into Butch in a good mood

"Come to the pet shop down the street:

"Be a good dog, I'll buy you a treat !" (Tag error)

Tush Tag different year 1999
Swing Tag Gasport mis-spelled s/b Gosport
P.E. Pellets
OakBrook mis-spelled s/b with small b

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items

 
TY Beanie Baby Huggy Rare with Tag Errors TY Beanie Baby Huggy Rare with Tag Errors
$250.00
Add to Bag

Condition: Good

Date of Birth: August 20, 2000

Tag on Ear: I'd love to be your special friend

I'll stick right by you to the end

So hold me close next to your heart

And from your side I'll never part ! 

Errors: This has the misspelling of Oak Brook on the tag as 'Oakbrook'.

There is a space between part and !

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 



Curbside pick up available
OR
click to ask about shipping fees
 
TY Beanie Baby Retired Original Rover TY Beanie Baby Retired Original Rover
$275.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Rare with tag errors

Date of Birth: May 5, 1996

On the ear tag: This dog is red and his name is Rober

If you call him he is sure to come over

He barks and plays with all his might

But worry not, he won't bite!

Errors Include:

-No UK after 5TX on swing tag

-No , after Oakbrook

-space between Birth and : on swing tag

-birthdate is in numbers instead of May 5, 1996

-space between numbers on birthdate 5 - 30 -96

-2 R's on tush tag

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items

 
TY Beanie Baby COURAGE NYPD the German Shepherd RETIRED observing Sept 11, 2001 TY Beanie Baby COURAGE NYPD the German Shepherd RETIRED observing Sept 11, 2001
$300.00
Add to Bag

Condition: Good

Date of Birth: n/a

This Beanie Baby was sold after 9/11/2001 with proceeds to benefit the New York Police & Fire Widows’ & Children’s Benefit Fund.

Tag on Ear: To honor our heroes

who lost their lives in the

national catastrophe that 

took pplace on September 11, 2001.

We mourn for them and express our 

deepest sympathy to their familes.

God Bless America 

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 



Curbside pick up available
OR
click to ask about shipping fees
 
Ty Beanie Baby Fleecie Lamb 2000 with Tag Errors Ty Beanie Baby Fleecie Lamb 2000 with Tag Errors
$300.00
Add to Bag

Condition: Good

Date of Birth: January 26th, 2000

Tag on Ear: Fleecie is cuddly and soft as can be
Give her a hug and then you will see
When you hold her close to your ear
You’ll hear her whisper “I love you, dear!”

Errors: Exra space in between Dear and ! in poem

Inside Tush Tag stamp is a number not a star

PE Pellets

Eyes are off center

Mouth is crooked



Curbside pick up available
OR
click to ask about shipping fees
 
Ty Beanie Baby Scat With Errors Original Ty Beanie Baby Scat With Errors Original
$300.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Condition: Good

Date of Birth: May 27th, 1998

Tag on Ear: Newborn kittens require lots of sleep
Shhh…it’s naptime, don’t make a peep
Touch her fur, it feels like silk
Wake her up to drink mother’s milk!

Errors include:

Dates on tush and hanging tags mismatch. Tush: 1999 Hanging: 1998

Space in-between "milk" and "!" on hanging tag and no space after the "..."

Says Gasport instead of Gosport.

 
TY Rare Daisy the Cow Beanie Baby with Tag Errors TY Rare Daisy the Cow Beanie Baby with Tag Errors
$500.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Condition: Good

Date of Birth: May 10th, 1994

Tag on Ear: Daisy drinks milk each night

So her coat is shiny and bright

Milk is good for your hair and skin

What a way for your day to begin!

Errors:

Date on the Swing Tag is 1994

Swing Tag letters are all in Bold.

There is an (R) after "Babies"

(TM) is after "Collection" should be an "R"

"Oakbrook" is missing the comma and space after it.

U.K. is missing after "P015 5TX"

There shouldn't be a space between "BIRTH" and ":"

Date on the Tush Tag is 1993

There is an (R) after "Babies"

"Collection" should have an (R) after it. Not (TM)

"INC.," Should not have a comma after it.

There should be a comma and a space after "OAKBROOK"

There is a double space between "IL," and "U.S.A."

"IL," should have a period after it.

No Stamp inside the Tush Tag indicates Daisy was not mass produced.

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 

 
Ty Retired Beanie Baby Original STRUT Ty Retired Beanie Baby Original STRUT
$500.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Rare with tag errors

Date of Birth: March 8, 1996

On the ear tag: Listen closely to "cock-a-doodle-doo"

What's the rooster saying to you ? (Tag error)

Hurry, wake up sleepy head

We have lots to do, get out of bed ! (Tag error)

A Missing after U.S.A P.V.C. Pellets.

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items

 
Ty Retired Beanie Baby Original Scottie Ty Retired Beanie Baby Original Scottie
$500.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Rare with tag errors

Date of Birth: June 15, 1996

On the ear tag: Scottie is a friendly sort

Even though his legs are short

He is slways happy as can be (Tag error)

His best friends are you and me!

It is an original Beanie and 1996 is the production year. It has the rare PVC pellets. The MAJOR ERROR is in the last picture. On the hand tag, the word “always” is misspelled “slways”. The second error is that it is missing the production red star on the tush tag. Check it out.

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items

 
TY Beanie Baby Retired Original Chip the Kitten TY Beanie Baby Retired Original Chip the Kitten
$1175.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


Condition is New with P.V.C. Pellets.

Date of Birth: January 26, 1996

On the ear tag: Black and gold, brown and white

The shades of her coat are quite a sight

At mixing her colors she was a master

On anyone else it would be a disaster !


REG NO PA. 1965 (KR) Korean
6th Generation Tush Tag! 5th Generation version 1 Hang Tag! Farehem Hants Location With spelling error!! (Fareham instead of Farehem)

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items

 
TY Beanie Baby Tracker the Basset Hound TY Beanie Baby Tracker the Basset Hound
$1250.00
Add to Bag

Condition: Good

Date of Birth: June 5th, 1997

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items 



Curbside pick up available
OR
click to ask about shipping fees
 
TY Beanie Baby Retired Original Hippy Bunny TY Beanie Baby Retired Original Hippy Bunny
$1500.00
Add to Bag
Price includes shipping for this item.
International shipping additional.


"Hippy" Bunny was born May 4, 1998.
On the ear tag: "Hippy" fell into the dye, they say
While coloring eggs one spring day
From the tips of his ears down to his toes
Colors of springtime, he proudly shows."

Missing . after Il and U.S.A

Ty Warner, founder of Ty, Inc. started a line of unique stuffed animals in the early 90's. Beanie Babies took a new spin on the classic stuffed animal. With small beads for stuffing the Beanie Babies had more movement which created a more realistic feeling to the toy. This feature set them apart from all the other plush toys on the market at the time.

Collector items